Blogger writes about predatory publishing, is threatened with $1B suit
Metadata librarian Jeffrey Beall runs the famous enterprise blog Scholarly Open get right of entry to. The website online maintains a listing of open-access journals and publishers that Beall believes interact in predatory practices. For journals and publishers those acts consist of such things as spamming pupils or charging faulty expenses for content material. The web page is thought genuinely as “Beall‘s listing” to fans and its notoriety has earned Beall inks in locations just like the big apple times. (And sure, now he even gets pseudo-spammer journals who request to be featured at the website online without truely information.)
Nowadays The Chronicle of higher education reports on a much less a laugh letter Beall received Tuesday. An Indian highbrow assets’ management firm referred to as IP Markets informed Beall that they would be suing for $1 billion in damages and that he could face up to three years in jail for his “deliberate attempt to defame our client.” That patron is OMICS Publishing group, an India-primarily based operation profiled several times on the weblog. The group asked that Beall remove the posts and updates to anyone who published his paintings, but IP Markets nevertheless intends to go through with the match both manner.
“All the allegation [sic] that you have noted to your weblog are nothing greater than super figment of your imagination via you,” the six-web page letter reads according to The Chronicle. “Our client understand the weblog as senseless rattle of an incoherent individual and please be confident that our consumer has taken a completely extreme notice of the language, tone, and tenure followed via you as well as the crook acts of putting the identical at the internet.”
The Chronicle spoke with one of the IP Markets legal professionals who emphasized the capability criminal activity of Beall‘s weblog beneath India’s statistics generation Act. The particular factor of contention, the frequently debated segment 66A, makes it unlawful to put up false material or “any facts this is grossly offensive or has menacing individual.”
Beall has faced lawsuit threats earlier than and other scholarly writer bloggers have even gone to court docket in such conditions (see Edwin Mellen Press taking over librarian Rick Anderson). Prison experts speakme to The Chronicle regarded skeptical over the validity of this movement, and the threatened possibility of jail time, but they did acknowledge a lawsuit in India will be more complex than if IP Markets had filed inside the US. Beall referred to as the amount “stupid” and stated the case had no benefit.